The Sounding Line

Charting New Waters

Negative Rates Are a Massive, Negative-Carry Short on the Global Economy

Submitted by Taps Coogan on the 12th of September 2019 to The Sounding Line.

Enjoy The Sounding Line? Click here to subscribe.

The only way to make money on a negative interest bearing bond is if interest rates become even more negative and you sell the ‘hot-potato’ bond to someone else at a markup.

Presumably, interest rates will only fall further if the growth and inflation outlook in countries with negative rates (Europe and Japan) continues to fall. Considering that the growth and inflation outlook in those countries is already bordering on a recession, I view negative rates as a massive negative-carry bet on a recession in Europe and Japan.

Investors are guaranteed to lose money on these bonds unless their bet on even lower rates proves true. With the exception of short-traders, very few investors have extensive experience with such negative-carry trades. By definition, negative-carry trades require very good timing. Exceptionally few investors have good timing.

The irony about negative yielding bonds is that they are supposed to represent the least risky assets in the financial world. In turn, they are generally owned by institutions and investors with the lowest risk appetite. In fact, most investors in negative yielding bonds are insurance companies, banks, and pension funds which are forced to hold the bonds for regulatory reasons intended to reduce their risk. Regulations aimed at ensuring certain critical institutions never take loses on their bonds now all-but-guarantee that they take losses on their bonds. How central banks have perverted our financial world…

There is now somewhere around $16 trillion wrapped up in the negative rate bond trade. It must be the largest negative-carry bet in history, by an enormous margin. It is also essentially a short trade on the global economy.

All of which begs the following question: what if we don’t have a global recession? If not, the most risk adverse investors in the world are going to get stuck holding trillions of dollars of negative yielding bonds, some with maturities as long as 30-years. They will either have to take big losses selling these bonds, or sit out whatever is left of this expansion.

Is this the largest short trade in history?

It is only a slight exaggeration to say that the greatest risk facing institutional investors today would be the lack of a recession. More precisely, they are doomed if there is a recession and doomed if there isn’t.

At the crux of this brave new financial world is a classic circular logic problem. The increasing size of financial markets relative to the underlying economy has made them the determinate factor in household wealth and spending. Household spending has, in turn, become the largest component of the economy in developed countries. Thus, household spending has become the largest determinant of the trajectory of monetary policy. Yet, monetary policy has become the determinate factor in financial market pricing. In other words, markets are pricing central bank policy and central bank policy is increasingly based on financial market determined factors. That’s what happens when you have a market based system and then let central banks manipulate all of the price signals.

As if the self-referencing doom loop of extreme monetary policy wasn’t sufficiently intractable, consider this: what will happen to global growth if the most conservative institutional investors in the world start losing trillions of dollars on an improving economy?

Would you like to be notified when we publish a new article on The Sounding Line? Click here to subscribe for free.

September 12, 2019 Taps Coogan

Post navigation

Another Great Rotation Looms → ← Why US Government Deficit Spending Isn’t Stimulative

5
Leave a Reply

avatar
wpdiscuz_captcharefresh
3 Comment threads
2 Thread replies
0 Followers
 
Most reacted comment
Hottest comment thread
4 Comment authors
B WildsTaps CooganDr. Donald D.A. SchaeferGreg Recent comment authors
avatar
wpdiscuz_captcharefresh
  Subscribe  
Notify of
Greg
Guest
Greg

How much unrest do you think there will be when a large percentage of retired individuals here in the US receive letters from their pension announcing a significant reduction in the monthly payment? While this has happened before to a relatively small number, were this to hit en masse it won’t be pretty.

I have to laugh, President Trump yesterday goaded the Fed to bring on negative rates. If it were to actually happen, he would be toast. Given these and many other pronouncements, I don’t believe that he really wants a second term.

Vote Up00Vote Down Reply
3 months ago
Taps Coogan
Author
Taps Coogan

Meanwhile, inflation is really not that far from the Fed’s 2% target:

https://thesoundingline.com/inflation-in-the-1960s-was-lower-than-it-is-today-then-it-went-parabolic/

Vote Up10Vote Down Reply
3 months ago
Dr. Donald D.A. Schaefer
Guest
Dr. Donald D.A. Schaefer

Please consider adding my recently published article through the Campbell Law Review journal entitled, “The United States’ National Debt and the Necessity to Prepare for its Default” to your web site. Here is the link: https://scholarship.law.campbell.edu/clr/vol41/iss2/3/ . Abstract: In many ways, the 2008 financial crisis seems like a distant memory one that many would just as soon forget. Another financial crisis is coming that will make the 2008 crisis pale in comparison. The future financial crisis lies in the massive national debt that has now passed the $22 trillion mark. The national debt continues to grow dramatically and, within the… Read more »

Vote Up10Vote Down Reply
3 months ago
Taps Coogan
Author
Taps Coogan

Thank you for sharing your interesting paper. I have added it to the Top News Story column.

Vote Up10Vote Down Reply
3 months ago
B Wilds
Guest
B Wilds

Thanks for a great article, well said! The idea that the bond market is a bubble about to pop is a subject not to take lightly. This matter has been scrutinized many times in recent years and little has really changed except debt has grown much faster than the economy in general. The so-called experts such as Paul Krugman in the ivory towers of academia in many ways pose one of the greatest threats to our economic stability in that they often fail to see potential second and third order effects of debt monetization. The article below delves into why… Read more »

Vote Up00Vote Down Reply
2 months ago

TOP NEWS STORIES

  • Chinese Trade in Hides for ‘Traditional Medicine’ Has Led to Global Donkey Massacre; Population Halved
  • An Abundance of Aluminum Scrap Spurs Investment in US Recyclers
  • China Says It Has Agreed to US Trade Deal Text
  • Coal Employment in US Cut Nearly in Half Since 2011. Most of Appalachia’s Mines Closed
  • Watch the Pentagon Test a Previously Banned Ballistic Missile
  • Interesting: Russia’s Economy Is Signaling an Oil Price Rally
  • Japanese Economy: Deja Vu – But Worse
  • China Suffers Biggest Dollar Bond Default by State-Owned Company in Two Decades
  • Germany on Alert as African Swine Fever Nears Border
  • Japan Looks to Strengthen Oil Reserves Strategy
  • The Vatican Is Using Donations for the Poor to Fight Its Budget Deficit. Less than 10% Goes to Poor
  • Ticking Time Bomb of Record High Corporate Debt
  • The Global Auto Market Collapse in Four Charts
  • This is How the Biggest Sector of the US Economy Is Doing
  • Scientists Discovered 71 New Species in 2019
  • Fed Will Flood Market with Gargantuan $500 Billion in Temporary Liquidity to Avoid Year-End Repo Crisis
  • Active vs. Passive: Why It Appears that You Can’t Beat an Index
  • The Oldest Cave Paintings Ever Found Shows Supernatural Figures on the Hunt
  • Picked by Slaves: Coffee Crisis Brews in Brazil
  • Oxen and Horses Put back to Work in Cuba
  • Feds Collect Record Taxes Through November. Still Run near Record $343.3 Billion Deficit
  • Global Stocks on Verge of All Time High After Fed Signals Endless Accommodation
  • Google Maps Tracks Everywhere You Go. Here’s How to Automatically ‘Delete’ What It Stores
  • Chicago, Detroit “Least-Prepared” for a Recession, Says New Moody’s Report
  • World Bank to Reduce Lending to China
  • Small Businesses & CEOs Differ on the Economy
  • Things You Shouldn’t Have to Deny: Saudi Arabia’s Finance Minister Rejects Claims the Kingdom Is Running Short on Cash
  • Abandoned Nuclear Missile Complex in Arizona for Sale: $400,000
  • Volkswagen Charged with Violating Vehicle Emission Standards in Canada
  • JPMorgan Warns of Rise in Emerging Market Sovereign Distressed Debt
  • The Long Fight to Clean up America’s Cold War Nuclear Waste
  • For First Time Since Manhattan Project, US Army Will Fund Rare Earths Plant for Weapons Development
  • Inevitable: Pedestrian Fatally Crushed Between Two Parked Cars After One Vehicle Is Started Remotely
  • Turkey Wants to Import the World’s Gold, with Fewer Questions Asked
  • Chevron’s $11 Billion Write Down Is a Warning for the Oil Industry
  • China Eyes New Energy Exchange to Expand Global Oil and Gas Trade
  • Archaeologists Unearth Hundreds of Cuneiform Tablets in Central Iraq
  • The Chinese City Struggling After Samsung Closes Its Last Factory in China
  • 2000-Tear-Old Iron Age Shield Discovered in ‘Warrior Grave’ in Yorkshire
  • First Commercial Electric Plane Takes Flight in Canada
  • China Remains World’s Biggest Jailer of Journalists
  • Gold Miners Expected to Continue M&A Spree in 2020
  • France Unveils Controversial Pension Reforms
  • U.S. Military Returns Four Bases to South Korea
  • Turns out Curious Head Cones in Ancient Egyptian Art Were Actually Real Hats
  • “Choose Huawei or Else”: Danish Island Chain Threatened by China Over 5G Roll-Out
  • India’s Largest Bank Underreported Bad Loans
  • Vietnam Tries to Crack Down on Chinese Made Products Being Routed Through the Country
  • Chinese Buyers Offer to Resell LNG Cargoes as They Struggle with Weak Demand
  • Argentina’s Shale Boom Hits New Milestone
  • Countdown to QE4?
  • For the US Navy, It’s ‘All Hands on Deck’ to Fix Endlessly Delayed, Strategically Obselete Aircraft Carrier Ford, the Most Expensive Ship Ever Built
  • US Deficit Spikes 12% in First Two Months of Fiscal Year. Over $400 Billion in Spending per Month
  • China Copper Imports Hit 13-Month High in November on Improved Factory Activity
  • German Trade Surplus Swells in October




Pages

  • Home
  • About/Contact us…
  • Donate
  • Commenting Policy
  • Privacy Policy
  • Disclaimer

Seach

Categories

Login

  • Log in
  • Entries feed
  • Comments feed
  • WordPress.org
Copyright © 2019 - TheSoundingLine.com | -All rights reserved
wpDiscuz