• Home
  • About/Contact Us
  • …Donate…
  • Subscribe
  • Commenting
  • Privacy
  • DISCLAIMER
  • Interesting Stuff

What Ails the US Economy

Submitted by Taps Coogan on the 4th of February 2017 to The Sounding Line.

The following graph illustrates the slowdown in US economic growth since the 2008 financial crisis and recession.

Data Source: Federal Reserve

The US GDP growth rate has slowed from an average annual rate above 5% to an average rate below 3% in the years following the financial crisis. Despite record highs in financial asset prices, many fundamental economic indicators have shown little to no recovery since the recession. Labor participation, capacity utilization, industrial production and many other indicators are still lower than before the crisis (see a list here).

This disappointing economic recovery has taken place despite the largest monetary stimulus program in the history of the Federal Reserve: one that was co-ordinated with similar programs at nearly all major central banks around the world. These programs have aimed to lower interest rates and re-liquefy banks via quantitative easing programs (QE).

Central banks have purchased a cumulative $16.8 trillion dollars in financial assets equaling over 35% of global GDP.

Source: National Inflation Association

The Fed has dramatically lowered its Fed Funds Rate since 2008 and with it other interest rates have fallen.

Data Source: Federal Reserve

The Fed has similarly succeeded in injecting banks with massive amounts of liquidity, producing record reserves.

Data Source: Federal Reserve

As a result of the Fed’s policies, interest rates are low, banks are recapitalized, and stock markets have rallied.

So why haven’t low interest rates produced underlying economic growth in line with historical averages?

Interest rates follow the same underlying supply and demand dynamics as other prices. Speaking in general terms:

When interest rates are falling it is a sign that demand for credit has fallen in relation to its supply. Falling rates mean that lenders are competing to lend to a shrinking pool of eligible borrowers. As the pool of eligible borrowers shrinks, lending slows, and so does credit creation. As credit creation slows so does the money supply and in turn inflation. Eventually interest rates become so low the lenders’ overhead costs exceed market interest rates. Below this point it is no longer profitable for lenders to lend. That reduces credit growth further and the negative cycle continues. All the while lenders’ (read banks) profits and revenues are reduced, threatening their stability and compounding problems further.

This is where the Fed steps in. To break the cycle of declining lending and declining inflation the Fed lowers its Fed Funds Rate. The Fed Funds Rate is one of the costs of lending for Banks. By lowering this cost, the Fed enables banks to resume profitably lending at lower rates than they otherwise would be able to do. Hopefully more borrowers will be credit worthy and more business plans viable at these artificially lower rates and credit growth will restart, ending the negative cycle.

That’s the theory. Here is why it hasn’t worked:

It is important to separate the root cause driving the cycle of weakening demand for credit from the symptoms. Declining interest rates and inflation are the symptoms not the cause of the current economic slowdown. The Fed has attempted to treat the symptoms not the disease. Accordingly they have had little success. Credit worthy borrowers did not become seldom because interest rates rose too high, borrowers became seldom because the financial crisis exposed, and compounded, growing structural problems accumulating in the US economy. These problems have only worsened since the crisis. Fewer people are creditworthy and fewer opportunities for economically viable loans exist as result of these problems, even at lower rates, and so credit growth has remained slow despite low interest rates. The chart below shows that the ratio of loans and leases to bank deposits plummeted following the recession and remains very low today. Banks can’t lend if eligible borrowers don’t exist.

Data Source: Federal Reserve

That brings us to the underlying problem: Practically speaking, the US has the highest corporate taxes IN THE ENTIRE WORLD (here). Large multinational companies don’t pay these rates, but small and medium sized companies do. These same small and medium sized companies have also been extremely disadvantaged by the increased cost of compliance associated with geometrically increasing quantities of regulations (here). Once again it is large companies who can afford the cost of compliance and thus gain a competitive advantage in increasingly regulated industries. As a result of over taxation and over regulation, the startup rate of new companies is the lowest on record and has fallen below the rate at which companies are closing. Disadvantaging small and medium sized companies undermines the US economy. They are the largest employers in country (here) and it is new companies, less than 5 years old, which account for all of the net job creation since 1992 (here).

The US economy needs dramatic structural reform: lower taxes and less regulation. The Fed cannot be blamed for wanting to help, but its attempts to manipulate asset markets and risk premiums have not only failed to produce real economic growth, they have created the exact kind of market imbalances that led to the last financial crisis. They have also distracted from the real problems.

For the first time since the last crisis, the US has political leadership that has articulated a strategy to cut taxes and regulation. Small wonder that strategy was so vehemently opposed by those whom have benefited from the overtaking of the US economy by large corporate and financial interests.

February 4, 2017 Taps Coogan

Post navigation

Europe is On a Precipice → ← Marc Faber Makes His 2017 Market Predictions
Subscribe
Notify of
guest
guest
0 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments

TOP NEWS STORIES

  • China Tightens Rare-Earth Regulations, Policing Entire Supply Chain in Geopolitical Power Play
  • Oil Majors Win Big as LNG Prices Soar
  • Palau’s New President Pledges to Stand with Taiwan, US Against ‘Bully’ China
  • Yellen Calls for Tax on Unrealized Capital Gains (Which Would Cause Massive Forced Selling)
  • US State Department Reiterates Fact That Several Staff at Wuhan Virology Institute Fell Ill with Covid Like Symptoms in Fall of 2019
  • SpaceX Acquires Former Oil Rigs to Serve as Floating Starship Spaceports
  • Steel Prices Are Exploding to Record Highs
  • With Tourists Gone, Squatters Take over Site of America’s Oldest City, Damaging It and Threatening Archeologists
  • The Mysterious ‘Alien Megastructure’ Star Is a Binary Star
  • Your Money or Your Economy; Why Productivity Is Everything
  • New Bat Species with Orangutan Hue Discovered in West Africa
  • Dinosaur Fossils Found in Argentina Could Belong to Largest Creature Ever to Have Walked the Earth
  • Europe, Canada Move to Put Boeing 737 Max back in Air
  • After Cotton Crackdown, US Retailers Told to Stop Buying China Forced Labor Products
  • China Develops Multiple Rocket/Cruise Missile Launcher That Hides in Shipping Container
  • Now That Universal Basic Income Checks Have Started, They Will Never End
  • China at the Heart of Rising Nile River Conflict
  • 30Y Breakevens Spike Above 16 Year Downtrend After Yellen Says “Will Explore 50-Year”
  • Arab Spring 2.0: Violent Protests over COVID Lockdowns, Economic Plight Erupt Across Tunisia
  • Pakistan Wants to Prosecute Online “Blasphemy” Committed Abroad
  • The Terrifying History of Russia’s Nuclear Submarine Graveyard
  • Microsoft to Invest $2 Billion in GM’s Autonomous Car Project
  • Uzbekistan to Abolish State Monopoly over Gas and Electricity Supply
  • Chinese Organ Harvesting Real and Still Happening, Say US, UK Legislatures
  • China Races to Build Giant ‘Quarantine Village’ for Thousands (They Ridiculously Claim Less than 2,000 Active Cases in the Whole Country)
  • Native Clay Pipes on Roanoke Island Sparked an English Tobacco Industry and Helped Save Jamestown
  • Europe Turns Down More U.S. LNG on Greenhouse Gas Concerns
  • San Francisco Techsodus & Unwind of Office Hogging Sink Office Market. Sublease Explodes, Leasing Freezes up, Rents Drop
  • Wheat Jumps as Russia Signals Prolonged Export Tax to Cool It’s Spiking Food Inflation
  • Germany Discovers New Covid Variant Among 35 Hospital Patients
  • The Pandemic Is Undermining Weather Monitoring
  • Iran’s Rolling Blackouts & Thick Smog Blamed on ‘Illegal’ Bitcoin Mining
  • Archaeologists Excavating Anglo-Saxon Cemetery Reveal 3000 Ornate Grave Goods
  • Japanese Utilities Hunt for Oil to Meet Robust Winter Power Demand amid Faltering LNG Stocks
  • Powell Sees ‘Exuberant Spending’ After Pandemic
  • Ireland Has Corals that Survive in Extreme Conditions at the Edge of a Submarine Canyon
  • China Possibly Committed ‘Genocide’: US Commission
  • NASA Test of Mega Moon Rocket Engines Cut Short
  • China Stonewalls WHO Investigators
  • United States Cut China Aid in Half in 2020
  • China Building Ground-Effect Vehicles to Defend South China Sea Claims: Leaked Documents
  • Massive Inflation in Shipping Costs – the Reasons
  • Quantum Internet Signals Beamed Between Drones a Kilometre Apart
  • Two Northern White Rhino Embryos Successfully Created. Finally a Glimmer of Hope for Species with Just Two Living Members
  • NASA Gives up Trying to Burrow Under Mars Surface with ‘Mole’ Probe
  • One Company to Rule Them All: Google Closes Fitbit Deal Amid Ongoing U.S. DOJ Review, Offers Empty Platitudes About Privacy
  • Race Is on to Commercialize Fusion Energy
  • Ukraine in Talks to Dump Kalashnikovs for NATO Compatible Rifle
  • Most Distant Quasar Ever Found Is Hiding ‘Biggest’ and ‘Youngest’ Black Hole
  • Russia Might Issue Fines for Using SpaceX Starlink Internet Service for Circumventing Government Censors
  • Astronomers May Have Detected Background Ripples in Spacetime Itself
  • Parler App CEO, Family Go into Hiding After Receiving Death Threats
  • WhatsApp Users’ Mobile Numbers from Desktop App Found Via Indexing on Google Search
  • 2,700-Year-Old Tombs of High-Ranking Nobles Unearthed in North China’s Shanxi Province
  • You Can’t ‘Just Build Your Own Twitter’

Seach

Categories

Login

  • Log in
  • Entries feed
  • Comments feed
  • WordPress.org
Copyright © 2020 - TheSoundingLine.com | Please read our full disclaimer and privacy policy before reading any of our content
wpDiscuz